We return to the Burger Chef murders case on the anniversary of the disappearance and murder of Jayne Friedt, Ruth Shelton, Danny Davis, and Mark Flemmonds ...
LISTEN FROM THE BEGINNING TO OUR BURGER CHEF MURDERS EPISODES: https://murdersheetpodcast.com/burger-chef
Check out our upcoming events and get links to buy tickets here: https://murdersheetpodcast.com/events
Order our book on Delphi here: https://bookshop.org/p/books/shadow-of-the-bridge-the-delphi-murders-and-the-dark-side-of-the-american-heartland-aine-cain/21866881?ean=9781639369232
Or here: https://www.simonandschuster.com/books/Shadow-of-the-Bridge/Aine-Cain/9781639369232
Or here: https://www.amazon.com/Shadow-Bridge-Murders-American-Heartland/dp/1639369236
Join our Patreon here! https://www.patreon.com/c/murdersheet
Support The Murder Sheet by buying a t-shirt here: https://www.murdersheetshop.com/
Check out more inclusive sizing and t-shirt and merchandising options here: https://themurdersheet.dashery.com/
Send tips to murdersheet@gmail.com.
The Murder Sheet is a production of Mystery Sheet LLC.
See Privacy Policy at https://art19.com/privacy and California Privacy Notice at https://art19.com/privacy#do-not-sell-my-info.
[00:00:00] [SPEAKER_03] I'm Kevin, and today we will be returning to the case that started everything for us, the Burger Chef Murders.
[00:00:06] [SPEAKER_02] Content Warning, this episode contains discussion of murder and violence, including the brutal murders of four young people.
[00:00:14] [SPEAKER_03] 48 years ago, today, the crew of the Burger Chef in Speedway, Indiana clocked in for the night shift. 20-year-old assistant manager Jane Freed and the three employees, 17-year-old Ruth Shelton, 16-year-old Danny Davis, and 16-year-old Mark Flemons.
[00:00:34] [SPEAKER_02] They never came home. After closing, someone abducted all four employees. They transported them from the Burger Chef restaurant in Marion County down to Johnson County.
[00:00:47] [SPEAKER_03] In a rural spot, they brutally killed all four of the employees in three distinct ways. Stabbing Jane in the heart, shooting Ruth and Danny point-blank in the neck and head, and using some kind of blunt force on Mark that led him to asphyxiate on his own blood.
[00:01:07] [SPEAKER_02] This case remains unsolved. It's perhaps Indiana's most notorious unsolved set of murders. No one has ever been held accountable for what was done to those four young people.
[00:01:20] [SPEAKER_03] We quite literally would not be speaking to you if it was not for this mystery. Back in 2019, we connected over our mutual obsession with this case. We fell in love, got married, came out with this podcast, The Murder Sheet, which began as an effort to catalog restaurant-related homicides to see if anything could be connected to the strange circumstances at the Burger Chef.
[00:01:46] [SPEAKER_02] Over the years, we released a miniseries on this show. We called it You Never Can Forget. That title was taken from a Burger Chef jingle. We went in-depth on the case in a number of scripted and unscripted episodes.
[00:01:59] [SPEAKER_03] Eventually, we stopped releasing so many Burger Chef-related episodes. We covered other cases that took up a lot of time and energy. That was part of it. Another part of it, if we're being self-aware and unflinching, was the psychological toll of Burger Chef.
[00:02:17] [SPEAKER_03] It's not simply that the case is unsolved. It's that after dedicating years to this case, we still don't know what happened. Because we care deeply about the case and the victims, that uncertainty makes us feel helpless and demoralized.
[00:02:33] [SPEAKER_02] So on some level, we feel that we both quietly drifted from the case. This wasn't intentional. We never talked about it. We kept looking into things behind the scenes when they came up. But we haven't done much public coverage of the case for a long while.
[00:02:49] [SPEAKER_03] But recently, with the anniversary on the horizon, we got to talking. We're going back to the Burger Chef case. We plan to release a number of episodes every so often to keep it alive and further the public's awareness and report what we know. Maybe if we don't give up, something good will come of it. We have to try.
[00:03:12] [SPEAKER_02] In the past, we called our Burger Chef series, You Never Can Forget, as we mentioned. This new series will be just titled The Burger Chef Murders. We want to distinguish it because it will largely not be scripted and we will be covering some of the same information, but with fresh eyes. We hope that we can do some good with this new series.
[00:03:31] [SPEAKER_03] Today, we start off this new project with an interview from one of the original investigators on the case, retired Indiana State Police Major Jim Cramer. He worked the case as a detective for a number of years, and he knows it very well.
[00:03:46] [SPEAKER_02] In this sometimes emotional conversation, he goes through possible but ultimately flawed solutions to this mystery, missteps that have harmed the case, and his own agnosticism as far as suspects are concerned. My name is Anya Kane. I'm a journalist.
[00:04:03] [SPEAKER_03] And I'm Kevin Greenlee. I'm an attorney. And this is The Murder Sheet. We're a true crime podcast focused on original reporting, interviews, and deep dives into murder cases.
[00:04:14] [SPEAKER_02] We're The Murder Sheet.
[00:04:16] [SPEAKER_03] And this is The Burger Chef Murders, 48 Years Gone.
[00:04:21] [SPEAKER_03] Who are you, and what's your connection to The Burger Chef case?
[00:05:08] [SPEAKER_05] Jim Cramer. I'm retired from Indiana State Police since 1999. In 1978, I was a trooper assigned out in Hendricks County. And I remember the night that the kids disappeared. So I'd been at Terre Haute. I heard on the way back, I heard over the police radio about these four missing kids. That was Friday evening. And then Saturday evening, they were still missing. And I worked all night.
[00:05:37] [SPEAKER_05] I actually spent a lot of time up around the Eagle Creek area, eastern Hendricks County, just checking abandoned barns, buildings, so forth. You know, why I did that, I don't know. Just on the chance that they were tied up or left somewhere. And then Sunday evening, when I went to work, I went to the post at Putnamville. And when I walked in, the trooper in charge that night asked me if I heard about these kids from The Burger Chef. And I said, no, did they find them? They said, yeah, they were all murdered down in Johnson County.
[00:06:08] [SPEAKER_05] And that hit me like a brick. And that was 48 years ago, almost.
[00:06:17] [SPEAKER_00] Wow. What were those early days of the investigation like?
[00:06:22] [SPEAKER_05] Well, I'm not sure the exact day. I was not at the murder scene, of course. On Monday or Tuesday, I was called and told to be at the Speedway Police Department the following morning. And I was involved there with about 15 to 20 investigators. And Speedway, Marion County, and so forth. There was a tip line established. Lots and lots of phone calls. Tips were all categorized on three by five cards.
[00:06:51] [SPEAKER_05] And we would start the day off in teams of two. And the folks in charge would give us each one or two leads to follow up on. We'd come back and write a synopsis of what we found out. And we chased lots and lots of leads. And that went on for weeks. We were very, very, very busy through the end of the year.
[00:07:15] [SPEAKER_02] So that was state police and local police? Like, what was the makeup of that general task force?
[00:07:21] [SPEAKER_05] Speedway was involved. Their investigators, a couple, Buddy Elwanger. And then Marion County had some investigators assigned. The FBI had been involved early on before the kids were found. And they'd done some really good background work in the immediate area of the restaurant. But once the kids were found, they kind of backed away from it officially.
[00:07:44] [SPEAKER_01] And unofficially, I assume.
[00:07:45] [SPEAKER_05] Well, they were involved a little bit. It's just law enforcement talking to law enforcement. So it's not like they were officially involved then.
[00:07:54] [SPEAKER_03] How many years did you work on this case?
[00:07:57] [SPEAKER_05] From 78 to Monday or Tuesday after the bodies were found. I worked on it continuously through 81. And then I was promoted and sent back out here to Hendricks County. But Don Lindsay and I had worked together from 81 through 85. I spent about 50% of my time in Marion County associated with the Burger Chef case. Still chasing down leads that were working at that time.
[00:08:25] [SPEAKER_05] And then I went to the FBI National Academy. And when I came back from that, I was assigned to our headquarters down to the state office building. And at some point, Superintendent Shuttle called me and asked me to go team back up with Don Lindsay full time. Marion County Sheriff had been involved with one of the suspects.
[00:08:51] [SPEAKER_05] And he thought things were getting just a bit out of hand and thought Don needed more assistance than just working on this himself. So I was involved then for about another year to two years full time.
[00:09:07] [SPEAKER_03] I think you know more about this case than anybody. And I want to ask you a question that I get asked all the time. Monty gets asked all the time. Who do you think did this?
[00:09:16] [SPEAKER_05] I don't know. You know, there's been times where me and any of a number of other officers from the state police or other agencies thought they knew. And really what it boiled down to in the end was a lot of different officers or investigators thought they knew who did it. But they were all talking about somebody different. And I'm sitting here right now telling you I do not know who did it.
[00:09:45] [SPEAKER_05] I think it boils down, based on what I know, all these years later to five to seven individuals or groups of individuals. And it could be any one of those. They're just not evidence to pursue any of these people. Or it could be somebody we've never heard of.
[00:10:06] [SPEAKER_03] Can you tell us about who's on that list?
[00:10:11] [SPEAKER_05] Well, I'm just going from my memory.
[00:10:15] [SPEAKER_02] Yeah, this is not a ranked list. This is more what comes to mind.
[00:10:18] [SPEAKER_05] Speedway, a lot of things were going on in 1978. And July, Julia Seifert was murdered at her house, seemingly for no good reason. I was not involved in that investigation at all. I know about it. But when the Speedway Police Department began to get some traction, or it seemed to me from what I know that they were getting some traction on this case,
[00:10:44] [SPEAKER_05] later in the fall, all of a sudden we had some bombs set off through Speedway in several different locations. The first one, coincidentally, being right straight across the street from the murder shaft. In fact, one of the employees who was murdered called the ATF with a tip. And I don't think the tip was anything that was monumental or whatever, but she made a call. So then you had these bombings.
[00:11:10] [SPEAKER_05] And then after the series of bombings, we had four kids taken out of the restaurant and murdered down in Johnson County. And that was the end of everything. I mean, logic would tell you that all that's got to be connected somehow. But it may not be. There's just not evidence to show that.
[00:11:31] [SPEAKER_03] I think a minute ago you kind of alluded to, for a while, Marion County was working with a suspect. That was Donald Forrester. Is he on that list you mentioned? Yes.
[00:11:40] [SPEAKER_05] And, you know, if I was ranking him, I'd probably have him down lower on the list than almost everybody. Donald was a convict. He was a liar. Unfortunately, he conned law enforcement. And he was taken out of the Indiana State Prison and brought down to Marion County Jail and kept there for almost a year. And eventually the prosecutor, Steve Goldsmith, had to get involved in sending him back to prison.
[00:12:07] [SPEAKER_05] And Donald Forrester had people from all the main leads we were working on involved in this case. But the main person he had involved in it after several weeks of looking and checking, we found out that person was sitting in federal prison the night the Burger Chef happened. And...
[00:12:25] [SPEAKER_03] Pretty good alibi.
[00:12:26] [SPEAKER_05] Yes. Now, Donald Forrester was from the Johnson County area. He was mean. He had been involved in lots of crimes throughout his life. He told people he was involved in the Burger Chef. But nothing he ever told me was credible. It's like he was making it up. He was doing a 99-year sentence for rape.
[00:12:52] [SPEAKER_05] Him and his cousin abducted a lady up at Castleton and took her out. And I think they intended to kill her. She was in the car and heard Forrester tell his cousin, head to the woods. And she hit the door handle and rolled out of the car. And it was the middle of the night and fled to a residential area and they'd never found her. And he was convicted of that.
[00:13:19] [SPEAKER_05] And he immediately, when he got convicted, started lying about all the investigators making things up. And he was just a con. I'm not saying he didn't do it because he's that mean. And he would have known the Johnson County area where the bodies were found. But he was a sexual predator. And neither of the girls from the Burger Chef were what's the word I'm looking for.
[00:13:47] [SPEAKER_05] They weren't accosted that way at all.
[00:13:50] [SPEAKER_02] I'm curious with Forrester. People might be wondering if they're not familiar with that story. Well, what would his reason be to lie? Do you have any thought on that?
[00:13:59] [SPEAKER_05] He told me personally that he was promised by the investigator from Marion County if he solved this case, they'd get him out of his prison sentence.
[00:14:08] What?
[00:14:09] [SPEAKER_05] Whether that's true or not, I don't know. But he was doing 99 years. So it's no skin off his back to make up a story. And he was living my life like a king in Marion County Jail versus the state prison.
[00:14:25] [SPEAKER_02] Was it a better time for him in Marion County Jail? Was that a better environment in his mind potentially?
[00:14:29] [SPEAKER_05] Oh, I'm sure it was. I've been in both places and I'd rather be in the Marion County Jail.
[00:14:35] [SPEAKER_03] You've been in both places, I'm guessing, as a visitor. Yeah.
[00:14:39] [SPEAKER_02] Yeah, of course.
[00:14:41] [SPEAKER_03] Yeah, as a visitor.
[00:14:42] [SPEAKER_02] Yeah. Yeah, I think that's important to note because, I mean, for someone in prison, that kind of jail might be a bit of a vacation.
[00:14:51] [SPEAKER_03] Right. We've got too much stuff in our house. Take clothes, for instance. We both lost a lot of weight recently after we adopted two husky mixes who demand 101 walks a day. That means we have a ton of clothes that don't fit us anymore, but they might still be useful to someone else. And why not make some money at the same time?
[00:15:14] [SPEAKER_02] Thank goodness for our sponsor Vinted, a terrific secondhand marketplace app that lets you make money off of getting your closet organized. Unlock the money in your wardrobe with Vinted.
[00:15:26] [SPEAKER_03] On Vinted, you get amazing deals on quality items. You sell clothing you no longer want or need, giving those garments a second life. Make money. Declutter. Streamline your wardrobe. Avoid waste and give those clothes a second life.
[00:15:41] [SPEAKER_02] There are no seller fees and the app is totally free to download. Try it out today. The whole thing is set up so you actually get to keep the money you earn. Vinted helped us earn extra cash, which we love. More money for FOIA requests. Plus, it was so easy to use. And it's made us feel better about refreshing our wardrobe with clothes we really love and will actually wear. It made clearing out our closet feel like a win, not a chore.
[00:16:06] [SPEAKER_03] See what's hiding in your closet. You might be surprised how much you can earn with Vinted. Download the Vinted app for free to start listing with no seller fees. Self-care isn't always about face masks and bubble baths. Sometimes it's about making time for yourself, discovering what you love, and feeling good in your own skin. Well, Melissa Boutique believes sex and pleasure should be fun and accessible.
[00:16:33] [SPEAKER_02] You can find their website at BBtoys.co, and I love it. It can be hard to find a toy you want and to feel confident it's high quality. No matter what your body craves, you can find it at bbtoys.co. They've got something for every sensation. Vibes, suction, G-spot stimulators, and even their special signature thump toys. When you order from them, you don't have to think about anything other than your own pleasure.
[00:17:00] [SPEAKER_02] Their women-run company has over 2 million very happy customers. Their line is 100% body-safe silicone, waterproof, and USB rechargeable. And every product is backed by a 10-year warranty. You don't even have to worry about anyone else knowing your personal business. Everything they send to you will come in discreet packaging and delivery. They're also running an incredible deal right now, and I couldn't resist taking advantage of it myself. I bought their Thermovibe, Airvibe Pro, Whispervibe, and Rose.
[00:17:29] [SPEAKER_02] I can't wait to tell you all about my experience with them. But for now, why not join me and become a very satisfied customer of Balesa Boutique. Balesa Boutique is running their Black Friday offer. They're giving our listeners up to 80% off everything on the site when you use our link. Go to bbtoys.co slash msheet for up to 80% off everything. And additional deals dropping daily. That's b-b-t-o-y-s dot c-o slash msheet.
[00:17:57] [SPEAKER_03] Trying to figure out how to get the right mental health treatment for yourself can feel overwhelming. Talkiatry can help. They connect you with real psychiatric care so you can actually understand what's going on and get a treatment plan that works. Talkiatry helps you move from, I know I need help, to actually having a psychiatrist who listens.
[00:18:18] [SPEAKER_02] Talkiatry is a 100% online psychiatry practice that provides comprehensive evaluations, diagnoses, and ongoing medicine management for conditions like ADHD, which I have, anxiety, which I also have, depression, and more.
[00:18:33] [SPEAKER_03] Unlike therapy-only platforms, talkiatry is psychiatry. You're seeing a medical provider who can diagnose mental health conditions and prescribe medication when it's appropriate.
[00:18:45] [SPEAKER_02] All 800-plus clinicians are in network with major insurers, so you can use your existing insurance instead of paying monthly subscriptions or out-of-network costs.
[00:18:55] [SPEAKER_03] This means you can meet with a licensed psychiatrist who takes the time to understand what's going on, builds a personalized treatment plan, and supports you over time with consistent evidence-based care.
[00:19:07] [SPEAKER_02] Getting started is easy and just takes a few minutes. Complete a short online assessment, get matched with clinicians who fit your needs, and schedule your first visit in days, not months. Head to talkiatry.com slash msheet to complete the short assessment and get matched with an in-network psychiatrist in just a few minutes. That's T-A-L-K-I-A-T-R-Y dot com slash msheet to get matched in minutes. Talkiatry.com slash msheet.
[00:19:35] [SPEAKER_05] I talked to Forrester. I recorded a long interview with him and basically accused him of lying, and he just never would come off his story. And it's like anything else. If you can prove somebody's lying about the main thing, you know that they're making everything up. And if he did it, nobody knows about him, and he passed away in prison.
[00:20:03] [SPEAKER_00] Yeah.
[00:20:04] [SPEAKER_05] And he's where he ought to be.
[00:20:06] [SPEAKER_00] Exactly.
[00:20:08] [SPEAKER_03] Another suspect, a group of suspects I have to say that we hear a lot about would be the robbery gang. What are your thoughts on that angle?
[00:20:14] [SPEAKER_05] Well, they're a logical group to look at. They were robbing fast food restaurants, Kentucky Fried Chickens. One of the group of four actually shot someone in a convenience store robbery. And they were from Johnson County. I always, it always struck me as odd as, why would you take these kids to where you're from? You know, if I was going to do something like that, I'd take them over into Illinois or somewhere not here.
[00:20:43] [SPEAKER_05] I was not involved in that lead extensively. I know about it. It's like the other. There's no hard evidence versus somebody said, this guy looks like the bearded drawing. And he shaved his beard off. Well, the bearded drawing and the short hair drawing that were, the composites were made back at that time, look like everybody on the street in 1978. That's the way people look.
[00:21:12] [SPEAKER_05] And there's, to my knowledge, no evidence. In fact, two of those fellows passed polygraphs about their involvement. And I know that. It was in the Indianapolis newspapers even. So, same thing. If they did it, they've got away with it to this point.
[00:21:30] [SPEAKER_02] Yeah, so basically that one, there's some plausibility because of the nature of their crimes, but there's just nothing that's that silver bullet smoking gun linking it.
[00:21:40] [SPEAKER_05] No evidence whatsoever to put them anywhere around the Burger Chef at night.
[00:21:44] [SPEAKER_02] I know there was the Cathcart statement that he made at the bar indicating, well, different versions of this have been told, but that he, don't worry guys, those kids, they just left them tied up in the woods somewhere, something to that effect.
[00:21:57] [SPEAKER_05] My memory, of course, we're talking about a long time ago, it was something along the line of in a bar and when it came on TV, he blurted it out. I know what happened to them. And somebody took that and ran with it. Well, anybody could have said that. You can see something on TV and say, well, I bet I know what happened to them. I mean, that's not a basis for...
[00:22:17] [SPEAKER_01] So, it was even more bare bones than it was reported. Yes. Wow.
[00:22:22] [SPEAKER_05] One of the four looked like the bearded composite. And there was somebody called and said, my neighbor was out mowing grass and he's got a beard like that. Well, how do you... How does that equate to they did this?
[00:22:32] [SPEAKER_04] Yeah.
[00:22:34] [SPEAKER_03] I'd like to talk about a couple of people who we do know were the very least in the vicinity. Let's talk, for instance, about a guy we've talked to on this program, the so-called gun tosser. This is the person he...
[00:22:49] [SPEAKER_05] I wanted to bring him up.
[00:22:52] [SPEAKER_03] This is the person he was driving erratically near the burger chef at the time the abduction was occurring. He's pulled over by police. He manages to throw something out the window and it is perhaps a burger chef cup that has a gun in it that is the same caliber as the murder weapon. It's not the murder weapon, but it's of the same caliber. What are your thoughts on that individual?
[00:23:18] [SPEAKER_05] He'd be up close to the top of the list. He was... There's not many people that we know for a fact were around that burger chef that night. We know he was there and we know a fellow named Alan Pruitt was there.
[00:23:33] [SPEAKER_02] With this man who threw the gun, who I think we called Terry on our show when we interviewed him. With that, what were the efforts around investigating him?
[00:23:43] [SPEAKER_05] The Speedway police got a call on Saturday that a Caucasian man and an African-American man were out of the car on 21st Street about 300 yards from the burger chef. I mean, you could see the burger chef from where this house was. And that they walked around like they were looking for something and then got in the car and left. That was Saturday afternoon.
[00:24:10] [SPEAKER_05] The fellow was mowing his grass or cutting up leaves or whatever. While he was doing that, he found a handgun. It was my memory. I don't know about the burger chef, Kevin. But they found a handgun there. And it was the same caliber, but not the weapon that was used in the murder. And we identified the African-American fellow because he'd had polio or something. One of his arms was shorter than the other. Several weeks went by, but we found him.
[00:24:37] [SPEAKER_05] And we took him and he, of course, he didn't know anything. And he agreed to a polygraph while before the polygraph even started sitting out in the hall. He asked me questions about it. And he just blurted out. He said, we were there looking for a gun. And the guy who was with, who you called? Terry. Terry. That's not his name. But he had got a hold of him and told him that he got stopped by the police that night,
[00:25:05] [SPEAKER_05] which is right about the time the kids would have been taken out of there. And that he wanted to go get the gun. And they went and looked and never found it. I would put him right up there in the top three positions where he was stopped, where he made a turn on Cunningham Drive and went down to 21st Street and the police stopped him. Somebody at the burger chef could see that.
[00:25:35] [SPEAKER_05] But, you know, that's only theory. Theorizing that. Was he involved in a robbery that went wrong? Did somebody else see the police cars and panic and take the kids out of there? You know, I don't know. There's no evidence to prove that. You're just speculating.
[00:25:53] [SPEAKER_03] Now, a minute ago, you were talking about people that we know were there. And you mentioned the name Alan Pruitt. So I'm curious, who is Alan Pruitt? How do we know he was there? And what was the story he told about what he saw?
[00:26:10] [SPEAKER_05] Alan Pruitt came to Don Lindsay and Maya's attention in 1980. We got called to the Marion County Jail. He was an inmate there and been arrested for something. He'd been in and out of jail, but minor stuff. Real minor. And he told us that he was in jail. And in the same cell block was Jimmy Freight, James' brother.
[00:26:37] [SPEAKER_05] And he knew the Freights because they were all from the Avon area. But he said that he made some comment to Jimmy about, I'm sorry about your sister, something like that. And an altercation ensued. So a counselor got out of there, called us. And we talked to him. And he told a bunch of different stories. He started with that altercation.
[00:27:05] [SPEAKER_05] And then he went to, well, I was there that night. You know, what if I was there? Like you see in true crime things where a suspect tells you a little bit and then backs away and then tells you a little more. He did that. He said he'd been at the Galaxy across the street with a friend, another guy.
[00:27:28] [SPEAKER_03] It was like an under-21 club. Right. And a hangout for care.
[00:27:32] [SPEAKER_05] A disco? It was a popular place back then. You could see the Burger Chef from it. And at some point around 11 o'clock or so, they went to the Dunkin' Donuts, which was right next to the Burger Chef, maybe 30 yards in between and 40 yards. And that they went in and the fellow he was with had been dating a gal who worked behind the counter.
[00:28:02] [SPEAKER_05] Alan said that he had been drinking, didn't feel good, went back out to his car, said he was parked between the Burger Chef and the Dunkin' Donuts. And David stayed inside. And that he came, David eventually came out.
[00:28:19] [SPEAKER_01] And his friend was named David. Yeah.
[00:28:21] [SPEAKER_05] Anyway, they went home. And I know that his mother found them asleep in their car and at their house the next morning, Alan's mother. Now, Pruitt said that while he was at his car, said he was sick to his stomach, he heard a bunch of yelling over behind the Burger Chef. He identified Jane as one of the people that was yelling. He thought it was a bunch of kids having a tussle, getting ready to go to a party or doing something. He just blew it off like it was nothing.
[00:28:51] [SPEAKER_05] Eventually, he threw in the name of two people that he saw over there. I know it's in the file. I read or I see comments that Alan was a liar and he wasn't there. He was there. How do we know that? Well, we know that because in the file, there's an independent witness who was in there drinking coffee,
[00:29:18] [SPEAKER_05] describes exactly what Alan Pruitt did, came in, went to the counter. The one guy stayed, talked to a gal. And Alan went out. That guy says that Alan walked over behind the Burger Chef and back two or three times, which Alan never admitted to.
[00:29:36] [SPEAKER_01] Was Alan distinctive physically in any way? Were there any features that would have made him stand out to somebody?
[00:29:41] [SPEAKER_05] Kind of looked like a wild man back in. He was just a kid. All red hair. He denied going over there. And the fellow that was with him said, no, that's not true. We parked on the other side of the Dunkin' Donuts. We weren't anywhere near the Burger Chef. Well, the other way we know he was there, the girl that this friend had been dating left the state right after the Burger Chef.
[00:30:09] [SPEAKER_05] I got wind that she came back to Hendricks County. And Don and I met her in Danville. And, of course, we knew what Alan had said at that time. We showed her mug shots, a book or a bunch of pictures, with Alan in there and this other fellow. She told the same story. This is a girl who was on the tracks behind the Burger Chef that described a bearded and a short-haired guy.
[00:30:38] [SPEAKER_05] And she repeated the same story she'd always told. Nobody came in the restaurant, Dunkin' Donuts, that I knew. All these pictures are showing me. You know, there's some people up from there, but nobody I know. Well, we narrowed it down to six with Alan and her guys she'd been dating in there. We confronted her with that. And she told us that, yeah, they were in there.
[00:31:06] [SPEAKER_05] And then she repeated exactly what Alan told us. And we were curious why that was just coming out now. Her words were, they were involved with some big-time drug dealers, and I was afraid I'd be killed. And basically, she lied for three years. We know she was lying about that.
[00:31:30] [SPEAKER_02] We also know that she lied about her description of at least the clean-shaven man because she told us that on the murder sheet, that she botched that description because she was scared that if she got it right, she would be put in danger.
[00:31:46] [SPEAKER_05] So anyway, Alan, I don't know what he saw over there. I know we can prove that he was in the parking lot between the Dunkin' Donuts and the Burger Chef. He described hearing this commotion. He described seeing two people.
[00:32:04] [SPEAKER_00] Tim Willoughby and Jeff Reed.
[00:32:08] [SPEAKER_05] Who he knew. And he said that they brought Mark out to the back of a van and that Jeff Reed picked him up by the back of his shoulders and popped his head off the corner of the van and dropped him like his exact words were like a sack of potatoes. And Danny Davis was let out and got into a van. And both girls walked around the building
[00:32:36] [SPEAKER_05] and he saw Jane's car leave and he saw the van fall away.
[00:32:42] [SPEAKER_02] So I want to emphasize something or just kind of get your thoughts on this. So what you're saying is we know Pruitt was there. An independent witness puts him there. His own admission puts him there. And even somebody who is an additional witness after three years puts him there. But at the same time, we don't know if he's telling the truth about what he saw.
[00:33:06] [SPEAKER_04] That's right.
[00:33:07] [SPEAKER_02] But we know he's there. So I know that's some nuance that I think some people don't appreciate sometimes. But it's not pointing out that Pruitt is important is not the same thing as saying that his story is accurate. It's just saying that he's there and he's telling some interesting stories. Yeah.
[00:33:25] [SPEAKER_03] And I would imagine if he was lying, it would be interesting why he was lying.
[00:33:30] [SPEAKER_02] Do you think it's possible that he knew that Tim Willoughby was missing at this time and that perhaps Jeff Reed had a reputation as a big tough guy and that he was filling their names in?
[00:33:41] [SPEAKER_05] That's possible. Alan Pruitt had told me when I talk about him giving information and backing away from him. At one point he said, I wasn't even up there that night. Well, by that time we knew he was there.
[00:33:54] [SPEAKER_02] Because you would talk to this older gentleman who's not connected with anybody who just happens to be there.
[00:33:58] [SPEAKER_05] Yeah, I didn't talk to him. But I saw the report in the file. Yeah. And he gave me this scenario. And he was tearful when he went through this. He said, what if I heard there was going to be a robbery? And I went there to see if it happened. And I heard that the burger chef was going to be robbed. Dunkin' Donuts was going to be robbed. Both were going to be set up jobs from the inside.
[00:34:26] [SPEAKER_05] And there was going to be a robbery of another place that night. He called it the Golden Eagle, but he claimed not to know what it was. He thought it was a bar. Well, across the street from the Dunkin' Donuts and Burger Chef, there was a motel at that time called the American Inn. Its sign set out there right across from the Burger Chef. On their sign was a big Golden Eagle. It was robbed that night about 730.
[00:34:54] [SPEAKER_00] The night of the murders.
[00:34:55] [SPEAKER_05] Yes. But you have to have evidence. You know, people cast Pruitt as a liar. And I think he lies. But one thing he can't lie about is the fact that he was there. He had an opportunity to see things. Just what he saw, we can't prove.
[00:35:13] [SPEAKER_02] If he was involved, he would have a reason to lie.
[00:35:16] [SPEAKER_05] That's right. And of course, he's passed away now.
[00:35:21] [SPEAKER_02] He would lie to us constantly. Like, he would just change his story. Like, one minute he's saying this, and then the next is that.
[00:35:27] [SPEAKER_03] She was a very frustrating person to deal with. Yes.
[00:35:30] [SPEAKER_02] So, but it was always interesting because it's sort of like, is he just making stuff up because he's kind of an eccentric? Or is he actively trying to muddy the waters because he's directly involved in something?
[00:35:41] [SPEAKER_05] He went to Avon High School. Jane went to Avon High School. Tim Willoughby grew up close to Jane Freed's house. You know, was he involved? I don't know.
[00:35:51] [SPEAKER_03] He and Jane knew each other. Yeah. Is it possible that there was some sort of a robbery situation and she recognized him? Yeah. I don't know.
[00:36:01] [SPEAKER_05] You know, I just don't know.
[00:36:02] [SPEAKER_02] But yeah, it's definitely some interesting possibilities there. I think when you have someone at the scene who's lying, I mean, I think the thing about the Burger Chef case is a lot of people have lied.
[00:36:15] [SPEAKER_05] Well, and people have said, well, if he told you that, why didn't you go arrest these people? Well, you can't just arrest somebody based on what somebody tells you. That doesn't make a case.
[00:36:24] [SPEAKER_02] You need corroborating evidence. That's right. Why was it so difficult to get corroborating evidence in this case? Like, as far as the crime scenes?
[00:36:36] [SPEAKER_05] Unfortunately, the Speedway police did not handle the crime scene there properly. State police made mistakes at the crime scene in Johnson County, but nothing like what happened at the Burger Chef. They came in for whatever reason. They thought these kids took the money and went out partying. And they let the assistant manager come in. I think the manager was there as well. And by 3 or 4 o'clock in the morning, the restaurant was cleaned up.
[00:37:04] [SPEAKER_05] And they actually opened for business the next morning.
[00:37:07] [SPEAKER_02] So even by the time state police comes into this, it's too late.
[00:37:10] [SPEAKER_05] Too late. And that's unfortunate. But that's, I mean, it is what it is. About the Johnson County scene, I wasn't there the day the bodies were found. I was down there a lot of times after that. Of course, I've seen the crime scene photos. And it was in the paper, and people speculated that these kids, nobody really knows. I mean, that goes without saying.
[00:37:40] [SPEAKER_05] I speculated that they were laid down and two of them got up and run. And Jane was caught, stabbed. Mark ran into a tree and knocked himself out. Mark would be here today, regardless of all that. If he'd have been on his side because he died of a bloody nose. Blood ran back into his lungs and suffocated him. But I grew up in the country. I've got a lot of woods at my house.
[00:38:09] [SPEAKER_05] And I can go through those woods in the daytime pretty quick. At night, if I was to run through the woods, my clothing would be tore. I'd have scratches on my face, hands, arms. You know, Jane was, I don't know how many feet. Some distance away from where the vehicle was parked. Her clothing wasn't tore. She had no scratches.
[00:38:35] [SPEAKER_05] It looks to me, and it's just my opinion, like she was led there purposely and stabbed two times. Mark, he has one, had one little neck. Almost like his jacket cut his throat. Just a tiny neck, almost like when you shave. But his injuries were all contained around his eyes.
[00:39:03] [SPEAKER_05] If you take a finger on your right upper eye socket, go across to the left, and down around to the bottom, and back around to the right. All his injuries were right there. And somebody beat him. They had something in their hand. Maybe a knife handle. Maybe a chain. Maybe brass knuckled. Maybe a sharp ring.
[00:39:29] [SPEAKER_05] All his injuries were little, deep, sharp cuts. And, of course, he had a bloody nose. But his clothing wasn't torn. He had no scratches and no defensive wounds. It looks like somebody started with him, and maybe he ran from the way he was laying. It looked like he was pulled down from behind, and somebody got on him and beat him.
[00:39:59] [SPEAKER_04] Danny and Ruth, they were laid down and shot execution stuff. And probably never saw it coming.
[00:40:11] [SPEAKER_05] And same way Jane never saw it. I don't think she knew what was going to happen. It was probably just that quick.
[00:40:19] [SPEAKER_02] Because, correct me if I'm wrong, but there was not, like, blood all over her in a way that she was struggling or defensive wounds.
[00:40:25] [SPEAKER_05] Not at all. So, somebody knows. Maybe they're dead. Maybe it was more than one person. Maybe it was one person. Everybody always, all the investigators said, oh, one person couldn't do that in the public. And I mean, that's logical. But I look back to, at that period of time, one person went into a pizza restaurant. It was not a pizza shop. It was actually a restaurant over at Terre Haute.
[00:40:56] [SPEAKER_05] They were, after closing, and abducted four people. And I don't remember the exact sequence, but they stabbed one, if I remember right, beat one, and then took a girl or two down to Evansville and held them in a motel. That was one person who did all that. They put a couple of them in the car and a couple of them in the trunk. So, is it probable that one person did this? Probably not, but it's possible.
[00:41:24] [SPEAKER_05] And that could be why nobody knows anything.
[00:41:27] [SPEAKER_00] Could be.
[00:41:29] [SPEAKER_02] So, one thing you mentioned was, like, you kind of worked on it for a while and on and off. And you mentioned, like, other people within the state police and with other agencies were looking at different angles. As far as this whole investigation, I just want to clarify, like, when people say, like, oh, you. Were the lead detective or other people were the lead detective. Is it fair to say that this was kind of like people pulling different possible threads as opposed to it being, like, one person?
[00:41:55] [SPEAKER_05] Right. One person or two people were responsible for the case at various times. Me and Don Lindsey for a long time. And then Stoney Van after that. Actually, when Stoney got assigned to it, I was kind of happy because I thought, well, somebody that doesn't have all this in their head about it could look at it. And maybe pick up something we've missed. Of course, I think he focused on the robbery gang pretty much and decided that was it. You know, what else he did, I don't know.
[00:42:25] [SPEAKER_02] Ken York was on it for a long time with the robbery gang side. Yes. And then, like, Johnson County, I know, had people on it. Marion County had people on it. Right. Speedway seems to be the ones who didn't really.
[00:42:36] [SPEAKER_05] Well, they didn't have the manpower, number one. And there were other things that went on. And I think they were overwhelmed. And there were some there that couldn't understand why we were so focused on it in the first month after it happened. And I thought, well, you know, there are four kids dead here.
[00:42:57] [SPEAKER_02] When you see people talking about this online, are there any things that you think should be cleared up or that maybe would be helpful for people to kind of focus on or talk about?
[00:43:07] [SPEAKER_05] I compare it to Delphi. You know, I watched that case. And there's a lot of the public out there that thinks they know what happened, but they don't. And it's real easy to solve cases if you can make things up and just decide, well, this is how it is, to the exclusion of everything else. And the public is not the only people to do that. Law enforcement does that sometimes. Confirmation bias. We've talked about that before. They hone in on one person and they ignore everything else.
[00:43:38] [SPEAKER_05] So, nope, it's got to be this. Don't mess up my theory of what happened. And I've probably been guilty of that myself over the years. But for the last 20 years, I've had a firm belief that we don't know who did this.
[00:43:52] [SPEAKER_03] When you think about it, are you like running through different scenarios in your mind? What did we miss?
[00:43:57] [SPEAKER_05] You know, just how it could have happened. You know, the bottom line is, I don't know. And anybody who claims to know exactly what happened, when you do that, you only embolden the people who committed this crime or the person who committed this crime. It's real easy to tell the public, oh, we know who did this. Oh, they're in prison. Oh, they're dead.
[00:44:26] [SPEAKER_05] The online stuff I see, there have been so many people who have come forward and said, my uncle told me I was involved. My grandfather was involved. You know, different. There are so many people that were involved in this that I had to have a bust. Convention center. People, it's their ego or something that they lie to people saying they had the gun from the case or that they were, you know, so-and-so told them they did this.
[00:44:55] [SPEAKER_05] Well, that's just people.
[00:44:59] [SPEAKER_02] It's a way for burnout losers who've done bad things in their life to have a brush of notoriety.
[00:45:05] [SPEAKER_05] Donna Forrester sitting in prison needed some credentials to show he was a bad guy so other inmates would leave him alone. Yeah.
[00:45:14] [SPEAKER_02] And it's a way for people who are bad people to scare their children, scare their families. And it's, you know, as you said, if all those people were accurate about having been involved, you'd need a couple buses.
[00:45:29] [SPEAKER_05] Yeah. If we could transport today back to November 17th of 1978, just think of what would be done different. We'd have phones that had their location all the time. We'd have cameras on the streets, cameras on businesses. The odds of something positive coming out, all that would have been good. We didn't have DNA. I know they talk about that.
[00:45:58] [SPEAKER_05] But that was just barely coming around when I left the department. So, uh...
[00:46:04] [SPEAKER_02] It's also not a DNA-rich case. There's no sexual assaults.
[00:46:07] [SPEAKER_05] No.
[00:46:08] [SPEAKER_02] There's no obvious source of offender.
[00:46:11] [SPEAKER_05] I believe they've looked at everything. I don't... You know, I'm not aware of anything that they've ever been able to have a comparison or have something to compare to.
[00:46:20] [SPEAKER_02] The long-shot hope is that eventually they somehow get something that has some trace DNA on it and it points to something.
[00:46:26] [SPEAKER_05] That would be great.
[00:46:29] [SPEAKER_00] We don't want to keep you too much longer. I, I'm curious, um, if you, if you want, would you want to say anything to the families that are still out there, still waiting on answers?
[00:46:37] [SPEAKER_05] Well, to the Freets, there's a brother and a sister are still alive. To the Flemons, a lot of them are gone. Mrs. Davis is, I know she's still alive. And, uh, Ruth's sister is still there. I just wish we had an answer for them. And I feel, I feel their pain.
[00:47:08] [SPEAKER_05] And it would be nice to know.
[00:47:10] [SPEAKER_04] I think about this every day.
[00:47:18] [SPEAKER_00] Are you okay?
[00:47:19] [SPEAKER_04] Oh, yeah.
[00:47:21] [SPEAKER_00] This weighs on you really heavily, doesn't it?
[00:47:26] [SPEAKER_04] Yeah.
[00:47:26] [SPEAKER_00] It was a big part of your life.
[00:47:29] [SPEAKER_04] Uh, 48 years.
[00:47:32] [SPEAKER_00] What would it mean to you if there were some answers gotten from it?
[00:47:36] [SPEAKER_04] I'd be happy for the family members.
[00:47:40] [SPEAKER_05] Unfortunately, that's, a lot of the investigators have passed on. A lot of the family members have passed on. You deserve answers for things like that.
[00:47:53] [SPEAKER_00] Do you, uh, I think I asked you a long time ago, feels like a long time ago, if you dream about the case ever. Do you, do you?
[00:48:00] [SPEAKER_04] Uh, I'd like, I'd like to. But I don't. But I think about it daily.
[00:48:10] [SPEAKER_00] Well, thank you so much.
[00:48:11] [SPEAKER_04] Thank you.
[00:48:12] [SPEAKER_00] And we really, we really appreciate it.
[00:48:14] [SPEAKER_04] You're welcome.
[00:48:15] [SPEAKER_02] Thanks so much to Jim Cramer for joining us. And we want to echo his feelings, his condolences. Our hearts go out to the surviving members of the four families. And to Jane, Ruth, Danny, and Mark.
[00:48:28] [SPEAKER_03] Thanks so much for listening to The Murder Sheet. If you have a tip concerning one of the cases we cover, please email us at murdersheet at gmail dot com. If you have actionable information about an unsolved crime, please report it to the appropriate authorities.
[00:48:46] [SPEAKER_02] If you're interested in joining our Patreon, that's available at www.patreon.com slash murdersheet. If you want to tip us a bit of money for records requests, you can do so at www.buymeacoffee.com slash murdersheet. We very much appreciate any support.
[00:49:12] [SPEAKER_03] Special thanks to Kevin Tyler Greenlee, who composed the music for The Murder Sheet, and who you can find on the web at kevintg.com.
[00:49:21] [SPEAKER_02] If you're looking to talk with other listeners about a case we've covered, you can join The Murder Sheet discussion group on Facebook. We mostly focus our time on research and reporting, so we're not on social media much. We do try to check our email account, but we ask for patience as we often receive a lot of messages. Thanks again for listening.

